My Approach

How I Research Candidates

Published: July 25, 2020
Updated: November
5, 2026

I am not a reporter and I do not do independent investigative reporting. All my research is done online using Google as my search engine. Increasingly, that also includes working with Claude (Anthropic AI) as a research and drafting assistant on select posts. When I do, you’ll see a note like this one at the bottom of the piece: “This post was researched and drafted with the assistance of Claude (Anthropic AI). The content was reviewed, edited, and fact-checked by the author. Both humans and AI can make mistakes. Please let us know if you spot one.”

I do not share gossip, rumors, or allegations unless in a published article from a reputable source that includes both the allegation and the candidate’s response. I exercise personal judgment in choosing which articles to include or exclude in my posts.

I subscribe to NewsGuard Ratings to ensure that the websites publishing the articles I cite or rely on are trustworthy. NewsGuard is a journalism and technology tool that rates the credibility of news and information websites and tracks online misinformation. It labels news sources with either a green or red icon, indicating general trustworthiness and whether there is a history of running stories labeled as fake news. (Wikipedia, 02/20/21)

Florida Politics is one of the few websites that consistently follow Florida elections. Its NewsGuard rating is 69.5/100 — “credible with exceptions.” There are cautions in the areas of “gathers and presents information responsibly” and “handles the difference between news and opinion responsibly,” which I take into account when I use it as a source.

Seeking Rents is a Substack newsletter and podcast written by Jason Garcia, an investigative journalist covering corporate influence on Florida public policy. It is a single-author outlet rather than a newsroom, so it doesn’t carry the layered editing and institutional fact-checking of a larger publication. Garcia is an award-winning reporter with a track record of original, well-documented reporting, and I take that into account when deciding whether and how to use his work.


Court and arrest records

Added November 5, 2026

Court records are public, and voters may want to know about them. I handle them with a written standard that applies to every candidate the same way.

What I check: For Collier County local races, I search the Collier County Sheriff’s arrest database and the Clerk of Court’s court records database for every candidate. Local races include nonpartisan and special-district races, city council, County Commission, School Board, and County Judge. A search can miss records, for example under a different name, in another county or state, or when a record is sealed or expunged. A clear search does not prove that no record exists.

I do not do a similar scan for state or federal races, but if reputable news organizations report a candidate’s court record, I may summarize that reporting and name the outlet.

Whose record it is: I report a record as a candidate’s only if I can confidently tie it to that person, using details such as name, address, and other public information. If I cannot confirm that a record belongs to the candidate, I do not report it.

What I report: From the last 10 years, I report pending charges, pleas or convictions (including adjudication withheld), and diversion or deferred prosecution programs. I always report any felony, any offense against a person (such as battery, assault, domestic violence, or threats), and any case that is still open.

What I do not report: I do not report civil, probate, family, or traffic-infraction cases. I do not report records older than 10 years. I do not report a non-violent misdemeanor that is fully resolved with only a fine and costs.

How I report it: I state a record exactly as the Clerk’s docket shows it, including the statute, the court action, and the dates. I never call a diversion a dismissal. I never identify or describe an alleged victim. The section notes that an arrest is not a finding of guilt.

The candidate’s response: If the record has not been reported by a reputable news organization, I offer the candidate an opportunity to respond before I report it. A candidate’s statement is published word for word, in quotation marks, and labeled as the candidate’s statement. A claim I cannot verify stays in the candidate’s own voice. I correct the record only where the Clerk’s or Sheriff’s records contradict it. If I become aware of a record after publication, I notify the candidate and update the post.

To ask me to change or remove a record, see my Corrections, Updates, and Removal Requests Policy.

Scroll to Top